Tuesday, May 25, 2010

Bernanke and the Depression of Damocles

It's showtime for Ben Bernanke, Fed Chairman. The moment of truth, so skillfully postponed by months of swapping good money for toxic debt, is once again at hand.

He will either be the hero or a punch line in some future Fed Chairman's speech.


The first lesson--economic prosperity depends on financial stability--seems obvious, but this connection was not always well understood. After the stock market crash of 1929, many thought a financial and economic crisis was necessary--even desirable--to wring out speculative excesses that had built up in the 1920s. Remarkably, despite the fact that the Federal Reserve had been founded to mitigate financial panics, the central bank made essentially no effort to prevent the wave of bank failures that paralyzed the financial system at the start of 1930s. Indeed, the Treasury Secretary at the time, Andrew Mellon, believed in the tonic effects of weeding out weak banks and famously advised President Herbert Hoover, "Liquidate labor, liquidate stocks, liquidate the farmers, liquidate real estate … It will purge the rottenness out of the system."

The Depression of Damocles hangs over his head while he deliberates long run strategies for managing the Fed's balance sheet- a hot topic at the Fed's meeting late last month.

The staff next gave a presentation on potential longer-run strategies for managing the SOMA. At previous meetings, Committee participants had expressed support for steps to reduce the size of the Federal Reserve's balance sheet over time and return the composition of the SOMA to only Treasury securities. The staff discussed the potential portfolio paths and macroeconomic consequences of a number of different strategies for accomplishing these objectives. To date, the Desk had been reinvesting the proceeds of all maturing Treasury securities in newly issued Treasury securities, but it had not been reinvesting principal and interest payments on maturing agency debt and agency MBS, nor had it been selling securities. One strategy considered in the staff presentation was a continuation of the current practice, which would normalize the balance sheet very gradually. In addition, the staff presented information on a number of other strategies that included sales of SOMA holdings of agency debt and MBS and under which the proceeds of maturing Treasury securities would not be reinvested; these strategies differed by the date and circumstances under which sales would be initiated, by the average pace of sales, and by the degree to which the timing and pace of such sales would be adjusted in response to financial and economic developments.

Ironically, the Fed is not debating whether to "liquidate" à la Andrew Mellon, toxic debt purchased from the banking sector, but rather the pace of liquidation.

The modern Fed, if it tries to drain liquidity by liquidating toxic assets, may well, like its counterpart in the early 1930s bury the economy under a mountain of unpayable debt in order to maintain a "strong dollar", which, as an aside, has risen roughly 20% so far this year in Forex markets.

Let's return to Ben's jab at Andrew Mellon, The first lesson--economic prosperity depends on financial stability--seems obvious, but this connection was not always well understood. Whether this first lesson is currently well understood at the Fed remains to be seen.

While there are many aspects of financial stability, one key feature is sufficient income to service liabilities, a task which gets most difficult the higher the ratio of liabilities to income.

The graph below depicts total US financial liabilities (source Fed's Flow of Funds data) divided by US national income (source BEA).

As you can see, current trends do not engender a sense of US financial stability. Income needs to rise to avoid a Mellon-esque liquidation. Financial stability, in my view, does not flow from support to financial institutions, which but buys time, but from a financially stable real sector. Right now, the last thing the US real sector needs is less liquidity and a strong dollar.

The question, in my mind, is why the Fed tolerates a "strong dollar". Will the words of men like Bob Rubin- "a strong dollar is in the US national interest"- become Mr. Bernanke's ironic epithet?

In time, economic historians may realize the only interests served by a strong dollar in recent times are those of the TBTF banks, who get a "free ride" on the exorbitant privilege of the US$'s role as main global reserve. Bernanke, to avoid being the goat, needs to solve Triffin's Paradox as Alexander the Great solved the Gordian Knot, by cutting it in half- and choosing to support the domestic (real) economy.

The real economy in the US needs a weak dollar and inflation or it will not be able to service its debt. How one can think finance needed the Fed's shock and awe in 2008-09 but the real sector doesn't, and can instead service its debt with a long and gradual decline in unemployment, escapes me.  The US needs some inflationary shock and awe.

"But," you might be thinking," hasn't the US been inflating?"

Yes and no. While the monetary base has tripled over the past decade, growing even faster than in the 70s, when it doubled, broader money stock measures are not responding in kind- M2 has roughly doubled during the past decade while it more than tripled during the 70s. Credit, more and more over the years, is flowing to the financial markets, (and overseas- some $300B of US currency is in foreign hands source: BEA) bypassing the US real sector.

Debates over the pace of Fed credit draining via toxic debt liquidation is ample proof. US monetary policy has been hijacked by international financial concerns who don't want the value of their dollar holdings inflated away (but don't seem to realize current income without inflation only invites default). 

Bernanke needs to make a choice. Supporting the TBTF banks and the "strong dollar" as basis of global reserves got us into this mess. More of the same won't get us out of it.

32 comments:

chris britton said...

I find your historical references in your entries to be useful for the financial illiterate among us refreshing. However, I think the more appropriate comparison for Bernanke is "between Scylla and Charybdis" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scylla).

I don't believe that inducing inflation will have the desired affect of reducing debt. There's no driver for job creation for those in debt and jobless to reduce their liabilities. Artificially inflating home prices via stimulus (and shadow inventory) has only gotten the Fed deeper into debt. Prices will start falling when the stimulus ends and there will still be high unemployment.

There's no hope for either of these choices.

Dude said...

cbritton,

I'm glad you enjoy the references.

As to the appropriateness of the metaphor, it seems to me to depend on the allusion one wishes to draw.

I've used the scylla, charybdis allusion before ( http://dharmajoint.blogspot.com/2009/10/from-black-scholes-to-black-holes-part.html )which doesn't mean I won't use it again.

We'll see what unfolds if the Fed ever decides to liquify the economy.

nilys said...

If we take money to be blood of a society/organism, then in my humble view the malady is not too much or too little of it; the malady is that the body parts do not work well. The Fed could manipulate the blood flow – do a kind of blood transfusion - and to a certain extent ameliorate the problem, but only that - ameliorate. Why do liabilities grow faster than income? The “strong dollar” policy was a conscious decision on the part of the ruling regime. Everyone knew that it would undermine US manufacturers and exporters, but be good to the US financials. The brush off was that US exporters would become more competitive. Why has “strong dollar” been in place? How have financials achived hegemony in the political life? Is it even Bernanke's call whether to have a strong dollar policy or not? So many questions, but focusing only on the monetary policy answers none.

Dude said...

biofuel,

Thanks for sharing your humble view that monetary analysis is useless in economics.

Masonboro said...

Dude: I am surprised you truncated the Mellon quote. It continues :

"It will purge the rottenness out of the system. High costs of living and high living will come down. People will work harder, live a more moral life. Values will be adjusted, and enterprising people will pick up from less competent people.”

This "social conservative" message sounds very current. Beck couldn't have said it better himself.

Jim

Tony Chew said...

Kami sarankan untuk anda yang pemula bawalah chip secukupnya atau modal yang sedikit saja untuk menghindari kekalahan yang besar diawal permainan sehingga
asikqq
dewaqq
sumoqq
interqq
pionpoker
bandar ceme
hobiqq
paito warna
http://199.30.55.59/dewaqq78/
data hk 2019

yugaganteng said...

paito warna terlengkap
paito warna china
paito warna singapore
live draw hk
live hongkongpools

werwer said...

Ummy Video Downloader Crack is an excellent application that not merely lets you download any video but will also downloads an audio file from YouTube. Just duplicate the connection. It will probably help save video files at any granted fps velocity for sale for preferred YouTube articles. It's possible to choose quality for downloading by yourself. YouTube will allow for a couple formats.

Amir Iqbal said...

Nice post
Smallpdf Crack

Shoaib Boss said...

Thank you for your time and effort and also for the depth of your posts.
the information you provide.
It's nice to come across a blog that doesn't repeat the same old things every time.
I really liked this book!
I've bookmarked your site and added your RSS feeds to my subscriptions.
A Google account is required to use this service.
microsoft office 2010 crack
anytrans crack
driver booster activation key crack
anytrans crack

Sami said...

Excellent information on your Article, thank you for taking the time to share with us such a nice article.
Amazing insight you have on this, it's nice to find a website that details so much information about different artists.
mindjet mindmanager crack
movavi screen capture studio crack
visual studio code crack
lucion filecenter crack

David malan said...

On the Internet, I was overjoyed to discover this establishment.
This was a fantastic read, and I owe it to you at least once.
It piqued my interest a little, and you were kind enough to keep it.
Become a fan of a new item on your site.
cubase pro crack
ocenaudio crack
virtual dj pro 2021 crack
pdftomusic pro crack

Instant Crack said...

I was searching over search engines and found your blog and it really helps thank you very much…
avg internet security crack software that protects all data you download online and utilizes this data for your work for the development of the websites and this data will be fully secure. avg internet security crack you use the app it will capture all the issues such as hacking and can save the passwords or your other information which is related to your site. avg internet security crack provides a fully strong shelter for all your accounts and all the important data. avg internet security crack you are doing the work of marketing and you have a list of links that you want to share with your trusted employer. If you want these links limited to only them, no one will be able to get these private links. avg internet security crack

Simple Boy said...

I was very impressed with his writing style and structure.
blog Did you buy it or change it yourself?
Regardless of the situation, the most important thing is to listen to new music with quality lyrics.
You rarely find a blog of this caliber these days.
avira internet security
lego star wars the skywalker saga crack
football manager crack
dominions 5 warriors faith crack
a knights quest crack
okami hd proper crack
underrail expedition crack
crab champions codex cd crack
tom clancys the division 2 crack

Unknown said...

Great Blog, Thanks for sharing this Amazing information. Very helpful for me.

Fury Unleashed Crack
GTA V Crack
microsoft project crack
Crash Bandicoot 4: It's About Time Crack



Naeem Shah said...

Thank you for your dedication.
to your website and the content you provide.
It's always refreshing to stumble onto another blog.
reprinted material that is unnecessary. Great job!
I've saved your site to my favourites and subscribed to your RSS feeds through Google.
pazera free audio extractor crack
goldwave crack
ashampoo burning studio crack
abbyy finereader corporate crack
sketchup pro crack latest version
camtasia studio crack
beyond compare crack
haozip crack

Artghural said...

It was quite instructive.
Your website is quite helpful.
Thank you for sharing your knowledge!
corel draw graphics suite crack
movavi screen recorder crack
tally erp 9 serial key crack
hard disk sentinel pro crack

Shoaib Boss said...

Thank you so much for sharing this information with everyone you know.
you really get what you mean! Noted.
Also take a look at my website.
We could come up with an alternative connection diagram among us!
jurassic world evolution license key
macbooster crack
adobe audition cc crack
gbwhatsapp apk crack
corel videostudio ultimate crack

Mahar Ismail said...

Hello there, I just discovered your blog on Google, and I like it.
is quite useful. I'll keep an eye out for brussels sprouts.
If you keep doing this in the future, I will be grateful. A large number of people will profit.
based on your writing Cheers!
vmix pro crack
wavebox crack
activatorjetbrains mps crack
istripper crack

John Cenna said...

Really Good Work Done By You...However, stopping by with great quality writing, it's hard to see any good blog today.
HQLicense
Ummy Video Downloader Crack

Nikfury said...

Let me express myself. I think your site has browser compatibility issues.
It shows you the location without any problems, but Internet Explorer has some overlapping issues.
In fact, I just want you to know what happened. Only this is the best blog!
reimage pc repair crack
microsoft office 2019 crack
ulead video studio crack
nordvpn crack
serif affinity designer crack

M Kaif said...

I am very impressed with your post because this post is very beneficial for me and provide a new knowledge to me.
Thanks for sharing this post is an excellent article. Keep it up. I use the same blogging platform that you have and have.
it Is Very Informative Thanks For Sharing. I have also Paid This sharing. I am ImPressed For With your Post Because This post is very.
fl studio
internet download manager
ytd video downloader pro
renowned explorers quest for crack
rage terrormania crack download

driver finder said...

Very Informative post, thanks for sharing.
iSkysoft PDF Editor Crack
ProgDVB Pro Crack
Serato DJ Pro Crack

Muhammad Sajjad Ali said...


I’ve been surfing on the web more than 3 hours today, yet I never found any stunning article like yours.
It’s alluringly worth for me.
As I would see it, if all web proprietors and bloggers made puzzling substance as you did.
the net will be in a general sense more beneficial than at whatever point in late memory.

total commander crack
coolutils total audio crack
auslogics driver updater crack
usb redirector client crack
aiseesoft mobiesync crack

CRack432 said...

This is an excellent online journal. More than that, I appreciate how rapidly I can access your website.
Which web host are you using, if any?
Please let me know whether I may include your affiliate link on my website.

Your website loads so quickly that it makes me wish mine did so, too.
poweriso crack
little snitch crack
download ms office 2016
activepresenter pro crack

maryam45 said...


Hello, Sweetie!
Your writing style is very distinctive compared to those of other authors I've read. Thank you for posting when you get the chance.
wi fi secret word programmer crack
smallpdf crack
cyberghost vpn mod apk v8 6 8 406 with premium unlocked all
valentina studio pro crack 2

masooma said...

Thank you for explaining this to me. I enjoyed reading your website. A society in which I can acquire information from knowledgeable and interested individuals.
idrive crack
easeus ntfs for mac crack
fonepaw android data recovery crack
593 2

CRack432 said...

I appreciate your kind words very much. As a reader, I enjoyed your work. You could have a knack for writing, after all. The evil Alvzis promises a comeback in the future in his blog and testament. Please keep up the excellent blogging and have a wonderful weekend.
adobe air sdk crack
sandbox crack
emeditor professional crack
tuneup utilities crack 2

CRack432 said...

To say I'm impressed would be an understatement. It's unusual for me to come across a blog that is both informative and enjoyable.
I simply wanted to mention that you did a fantastic job.
Few people, male or female, have the mental capacity to articulate a problem in a rational manner.
I'm very grateful that this trip helped me figure out who I am.
cool edit pro full crack
isobuster crack
web freer crack
acronis true image crack

cutegirl said...


it is the best website for all of us. it provides all types of software which we need. you can visit this website.
livein2pcm
vstpc
topcracker
crackedfreepcm

Tehreem said...

Thank you for your explanation. I thoroughly enjoyed reading your webpage. A community where I may obtain information from knowledgeable and interested members.
https://christinanysites.blogspot.com/2021/07/uc-browser-2021-uc-browser-2021-uc.html
https://mattsx360blog.blogspot.com/2021/05/internet-download-manager-free-download.html
https://tcraftt.blogspot.com/2021/06/idm-free-trail-download-internet.html
https://deupie.blogspot.com/2021/05/business-cards-maker-digital-business.html

pro crack work said...


Wow, that's a fantastic outcome.
I value the work you have done into my education.
jriver media center crack
masstube plus crack
composing expert genius free download
easeus parcel expert free download